Admission of Guilt! A Reply to Mish

Mish over at the Global Economic Analysis asks the following in the comments section:

“Can I ask a question?

With oil at $84 ....
Where is Oil Shock?

Mish
Like this comment?
link to the post

Oil Shock was indeed wrong. Yes, I called the bottom at $90 for oil. It was indeed the bottom until Oil declined one more time. Yes, so far it about 7% below that price. I still have called a perfect bottom in gold. Dollar index is about 2% higher than my prediction top.

Australian Dollar cliff dived yesterday, partly due to the unwinding of the carry trade. Just two months ago, the Ozzie was at near parity with the USD, but today you could buy 1 Ozzie for 64 cents U.S. Do you think Australian economy is fundamentally a lot weaker than the U.S economy? Do you think what happened to Iceland and Australia are impossible to happen here?

Much of the strength in dollar index is due to the weakness of Euro, it is not an indication of Dollar strength. Euro is a doomed currency. I heard somebody put it as the Deutsche Mark + some parasites, and that is very true.

Was my bottom and top calls based on any specific formula? No. It was just rhetoric meant to say that inflation is still in play. Did I strongly believe in my prediction? Yes I did. Did I know that for 100% sure that Oil will bottom at $90.00, and Gold at $750? No I did not.

As for all those deflationary derivatives worth 500 trillion floating around, it is all hogwash. Derivatives can go to zero and 80-90% of them do, even in a bull market. Have you read stats on options? Most of them go to zero? If one were to really believe that those derivatives are part of the money supply, what do you think the price of a refrigerator full of groceries would be?

Is there an unwillingness to lend right now? Yes. But all the debt will be monetized away, and some more will be accumulated by the local, state, and federal governments and monetized.

Stop kidding yourself. Oil at $84 is a lot higher than were it was, when Mish started denying that inflation was non-existent, go back, he has a lot of charts and graphs starting from 2005 to prove his point.

Mish has been consistently wrong for many years with his predictions, and yet he needs a great deal of credit for predicting the crisis very accurately as it unfolded. There were a lot of guys predicting shallow recessions, muddle throughs etc. But Mish could see a lot further than those others; he predicted a deeper recession. He was just a little early. Mish is still wrong about deflation.

Real wealth is ability to produce real goods, and that is one area that American economy lacks clearly. Yes, America has a lot of productive capacity, but no where close the purported size of the economy. So, what really is backing our dollar? yes,a lot of productive capacity, and a lot more of hot air.